Atma Jyoti Ashram is located in Cedar Crest, New Mexico, USA, and is dedicated to living the traditional Hindu monastic life.
 



Visit the new
Atma Jyoti Blog
 
 
 

tell a friendCommentary on the Prashna Upanishad–by Swami Nirmalananda Giri

rishi

The Powers That Make Us “Be”

Each of us is both Who and What. The Who is simple to define: Individualized Consciousness or jivatman–Individualized Self. The What, on the other hands is quite complex, which is why we have gotten lost in it and confused for lifetimes beyond number. The first step in learning how to undo this dilemma is learning what is keeping it going. For that reason:

“Then Bhargava approached the teacher and asked: ‘Holy sir, how many several powers1 hold together this body? Which of them are most manifest in it? And which is the greatest?’” (Prashna Upanishad 2:1) We need to know who our jailers are and especially who the governor of the jail may be. So:

Our makeup

“‘The powers,’ replied the sage, ‘are ether, air, fire, water, earth–these being the five elements which compose the body; and, besides these, speech, mind, eye, ear, and the rest of the sense organs. Once these powers made the boastful assertion: “We hold the body together and support it”’” (Prashna Upanishad 2:2)

The five elements (panchabhuta) are forms of cosmic energy which make up the various bodies of the human being, including the five senses. They are not passive, but are living and moving powers. However, Bhargava has asked which powers hold together the body, which itself is formed of the elemental forces. Only one of them is the cohesive force which keeps the others in its magnetic field and enables them to assume form and function within that form. To illustrate this, Pippalada gave him a parable, saying that once all the elements claimed to be the dominant force in the body.

Prana

“Whereupon Prana, the primal energy, supreme over them all, said to them: ‘Do not deceive yourselves. It is I alone, dividing myself fivefold, who hold together this body and support it.’ But they would not believe him.” (Prashna Upanishad 2:3)

Even the smallest particle of the cosmos is the Universal Life in manifestation.

We see from this that the five elements are modifications of the cosmic life, the Prana (Vishwaprana), that although the body seems to be formed only of the five elements, the Prana itself is the underlying substratum as the ocean is to the waves. The body, then, is really nothing but Prana, as is anything else in the realm of relative existence. Even the smallest particle of the cosmos is the Universal Life in manifestation.

Another point is the supposed conversation between the elements. This is not just a device in a fable, but is an indication that since all things are manifestations of Cosmic Life they can take on a seemingly independent life (and even consciousness) of their own. This is a fundamental trait of Maya, the Cosmic Illusion, one which lies at the root of most confusion and ignorance.

The proof

“Prana, to justify himself, made as if he intended to leave the body. But as he rose and appeared to be going, all the rest realized that if he went they also would have to depart with him; and as Prana again seated himself, the rest found their respective places. As bees go out when their queen goes out, and return when she returns, so was it with speech, mind, vision, hearing, and the rest. Convinced of their error, the powers now praised Prana, saying:” (Prashna Upanishad 2:4)

All the elements of the cosmos are rooted in Prana. It is the same with the elements and the senses in the individual’s body complex (for the human being has five bodies corresponding to the five elements). Just as the waves are in total dependence upon the ocean for their very being, so everything cosmic and microcosmic depend upon Prana. This is why Om is called the Pranava: It is the sound-form of Prana, the mantric syllable by which the Prana is contacted and controlled. Furthermore, the breath (also called prana) is the outermost, physical manifestation of prana. Because of this the yogi joins his inner intonations of Om to his breath in the highest form of pranayama.

Pranayama is accomplished by effortlessly breathing and joining to it the repetition of the sacred Om.

“That which causes all the pranas to prostrate themselves before and get merged in the Paramatman [the Supreme Soul: God], so as to attain identity with Him, is for that reason known as the Pranava.” (Atharvashikha Upanishad 1:10) “With Om alone he should breathe.” (Amritabindu Upanishad 20) “Pranayama is accomplished through concentrating the mind on Om.” (Saubhagyalakshmi Upanishad) “The Pranava alone becomes the pranayama.” (Shandilya Upanishad 6:2 ) “Pranayama is composed of the Pranava, Om. [Therefore] he should repeat the Pranava mentally. This only will be pranayama.” (Darshan Upanishad 6:2,5,6) “Pranayama is accomplished by effortlessly breathing and joining to it the repetition of the sacred Om.” (Yoga Vashishtha 5:78)

The powers of Prana

He who controls Prana controls all since Prana is all. Therefore the elements praised Prana, saying:

“ ‘As fire, Prana bums; as the sun, he shines; as cloud, he rains; as Indra, he rules the gods; as wind, he blows; as the moon, he nourishes all. He is that which is visible and also that which is invisible. He is immortal life.

“ ‘As spokes in the hub of a wheel, so is everything made fast in Prana–the Rik, the Yajur, the Sama, all sacrifices, the Kshatriyas, and the Brahmins.

“ ‘O Prana, lord of creation, thou movest in the womb, and art born again. To thee who, as breath, dwellest in the body, all creatures bring offerings.

“ ‘Thou, as fire, dost carry oblations to the gods; and through thee the fathers receive their offerings. To every organ of sense thou givest its function.

“ ‘Prana, thou art the creator; thou art the destroyer by thy prowess; and thou art the protector. Thou movest in the sky as the sun, and lord of lights art thou.

“ ‘Prana, when thou showerest down rain, thy creatures rejoice, hoping that they will find food, as much as they desire.

“ ‘Thou art purity itself, thou art the master of all that exists, thou art fire, the eater of offerings. We, the organs of sense, offer to thee thy food–to thee, the father of all.

“ ‘That power of thine which dwells in speech, in the ear, and in the eye, and which pervades the heart–make that propitious, and forsake us not.

“ ‘Whatsoever exists in the universe is dependent on thee, O Prana. Protect us as a mother protects her children. Grant us prosperity and grant us wisdom.’” (Prashna Upanishad 2:5-13)

Obviously, then, the yogi cannot neglect the cultivation of Prana and Pranava together.


More from the Upanishads:

An Introduction to the Upanishads
Selections from the Text of the Upanishads
from The Upanishads: Breath of the Eternal–translated by Swami Prabhavananda and Frederick Manchester
The Isha Upanishad
The Katha Upanishad
The Taittiriya Upanishad
The Aitareya Upanishad
The Kena Upanishad
The Prashna Upanishad
The Mundaka Upanishad
The Mandukyka Upanishad

Commentaries on the Upanishads by Swami Nirmalananda Giri
Katha Upanishad:
1. The Past is the Future
2. Seeing Death, Seeing Life
3. The Good and the Pleasant
4. The Way of Ignorance
5. The Mystery of the Self
6. How to Either Know or Not Know the Self
7. From the Unreal to the Real
8. Finding the Treasure
9. The Transcendent Reality of the Self
10. The Immortal Self
11. The Indwelling Self
12. The Omnipresent Self
13. The Sorrowless Self
14. Who Can Know the Self?
15. The All-Consuming Self
16. The Divine Indwellers
17. The Chariot
18. The Chariot's Journey
19. The Glorious Way
20. To Know The Self
21. The Power of Enlightenment
22. The Infinite Self
23. The Dweller in the Heart
24. The Birthless Self
25. The Shining Self
26. The Life-Giving Self
27. The Eternal Brahman–The Eternal Self
28. The Radiant Self
29. The Universal Tree
30. Hierarchy of Consciousness
31. From Mortality to Immortality

Isha Upanishad: Kena Upanishad:
1. Seeing All Things in God
2. Living a Life Worth Living
3. Spiritual Suicides
4. The Undivided Unmoving Self
5. The Ever-Present Self
6. The All-Embracing Self
7. Perspective on Life
8. Seeing Beyond the Sun
9. The Final Aspiration
1. The Mover of the Moved
2. Knowing that is Ignorance, and Unknowing That is Knowing
3. The Blessed
4. Approaching Brahman

Prashna Upanishad: Mundaka Upanishad:
1. The Right Beginning
2. The Father and Mother of All
3. The Powers That Make Us “Be”
4. Prana: Its History and Nature
5. The Witnessing Self
6. Meditation on Om
7. Where is the Self?
1. Knowing the ALL
2. Delusion and Ignorance
3. Wisdom and Truth
4. Getting in Perspective
5. Origin and Return
6. Knowing God
7. The Two Selves
8. The God Within, The Sage Without
9. Hail To the Sages!

1) The word Swami Prabhavananda translates “power” is deva: god. He chose this interpretive translation so we could better understand the meaning of the sage’s words. [Go back]

 
Web design by Webpublishing.com Copyright Atma Jyoti Ashram ©2004